Carbon Steel Griddles

Ahmad Rosales
11 min readJun 18, 2024


If you’re a fervent outdoor cooker, a Carbon Steel Griddle should be at the top of your wish list! This versatile and durable piece of cookware provides a seamless cooking experience for all your favorite BBQ dishes. In this roundup, we’ll explore the finest carbon steel griddle options on the market, evaluating their features, durability, and performance to equip you with the griddle that matches your culinary ambitions.

The Top 5 Best Carbon Steel Griddles

  1. Lodge Carbon Steel 18-inch Pre-Seasoned Griddle — Experience the versatility and durability of Lodge’s 18-inch Carbon Steel Griddle, boasting a lightweight design, even heat distribution, and non-stick ease for all your cooking needs.
  2. Oklahoma Joe’s Rider Carbon Steel Griddle for Versatile Cooking — The Oklahoma Joe’s Rider Carbon Steel Griddle offers an extra-large 19-inch diameter surface for cooking a crowd, with heavy-duty 12-gauge carbon steel construction for durability and versatility on smokers, grills, ovens, and stove tops.
  3. Carbon Steel Griddle with Lightweight Design and Non-Stick Coating — Experience the perfect blend of natural non-stick performance, easy maintenance, and precise temperature control with our Carbon Steel Griddle, designed to bring your favorite restaurant dishes straight to your home.
  4. Lodge Carbon Steel Seasoned Griddle 18" x 10 — Transform your outdoor cooking experience with the Lodge CRSGR18 Seasoned 18" x 10" Carbon Steel Griddle, featuring easy-release seasoning, sturdy steel riveted handles, and an excellent heat distribution for perfect dishes every time.
  5. Zadora Premium 14" Carbon Steel Griddle — Zadora 14" Carbon Steel Comal, Red: A versatile griddle with even heat distribution, non-stick interior for healthier cooking, and excellent for serving or covering other pots on the stove, but lacking robust durability and prone to food sticking.

As an Amazon Associate, we receive compensation from qualifying purchases!


Lodge Carbon Steel 18-inch Pre-Seasoned Griddle


Lodge’s 18-inch Carbon Steel Griddle is perfect for those who love cooking a diverse array of meals. With its large surface and impressive heat retention, it’s an excellent addition to your kitchen or grill.

Made from high-grade 12-gauge carbon steel, this griddle is not only durable but easy to maneuver — a plus when dealing with multiple culinary creations. The 100% natural vegetable oil seasoning ensures a perfect, smooth non-stick finish, making cleaning a breeze.

Lodge’s griddle is versatile, oven-safe, and capable of withstanding heat, whether on a gas stove, grill, or over a campfire. However, it’s important to note that it’s not recommended for use on smooth-top stoves. Despite a few minor drawbacks, this griddle maintains a high rating from satisfied customers, indicating a product of unparalleled quality and ease of use.

Oklahoma Joe’s Rider Carbon Steel Griddle for Versatile Cooking


The Oklahoma Joe’s Rider Carbon Steel Griddle is a generous 19-inch griddle, making it perfect for cooking for a crowd. Made from heavy-duty 12-gauge carbon steel, it’s more durable and lighter than traditional cast iron. The griddle’s versatility allows it to fit most smokers, grills, ovens, and stove tops, making it an all-around excellent accessory.

Designed to fit seamlessly with Oklahoma Joe’s Rider and Rider DLX Pellet Grills, this griddle features a Flex Grate, which allows for easy removal of the round cooking grate and insertion of the griddle. Measuring 19 inches in diameter and 5 inches high, it’s a generous size that caters to all your cooking needs, from breakfast to dinner and everything in between.

With its lightweight construction and consistent, even heat distribution, the griddle proves to be a breeze to maneuver and heat up. Its surface is perfect for cooking a wide variety of dishes, from bacon to pancakes to steak, on your smoker or grill. The Oklahoma Joe’s Rider Carbon Steel Griddle is a must-have for anyone who values convenience and versatility in their outdoor cooking experiences.

However, some users have expressed dissatisfaction with the pan’s ability to conduct and hold heat effectively, likening it to cast iron. Additionally, concerns regarding the product’s compatibility with specific grills and the difficulty of returning the product in certain cases have led to mixed reviews. Overall, the Oklahoma Joe’s Rider Carbon Steel Griddle is a valuable addition to any outdoor kitchen, boasting convenience, a generous size, and customization options that make it a worthwhile investment.

Carbon Steel Griddle with Lightweight Design and Non-Stick Coating


Made with carbon steel, this griddle offers a perfect blend of cast iron’s heat retention and stainless clad’s control and maneuverability. The griddle’s natural non-stick surface is pre-seasoned with a mixture of three oils, enhancing its overall performance right out of the box. Its lightweight design allows for easy transportation from stove to grill and fits over two burners for dual-zone cooking. The griddle is compatible with electric, gas, and induction cooktops, allowing for versatility in your kitchen. The unique design maximizes direct heat contact, ensuring crispy edges on smash burgers, hash browns, and grilled cheese.

The hand-welded, raised handles with optional Italian leather covers provide a comfortable and ergonomic carrying experience. Additionally, the sloping sides help contain excess moisture and grease, preventing messy spills. It seems that this highly-rated griddle has become a popular choice among home cooks, unlocking the potential for restaurant-quality dishes in the comfort of their own kitchen.

Lodge Carbon Steel Seasoned Griddle 18" x 10


This Lodge griddle is a fantastic addition to any cooking enthusiast’s collection. With a large 18" x 10" cooking surface, it provides ample space to whip up pancakes, pilafs, and more. Made from heavy-duty 12-gauge carbon steel, this griddle is perfect for home use or camping trips. The seasoned finish with a vegetable oil formula ensures a non-stick surface that improves with use. Moreover, the steel riveted handles offer a sturdy grip, while the product is proudly made in the USA.

Key features that make this griddle stand out include its sturdiness and heat distribution. However, users do mention that the pan requires some additional seasoning out of the box and that it might slightly smoke on low heat. Despite these minor drawbacks, many reviewers appreciate the ease of cleaning and the great taste it adds to their meals.

Transform your grill into a short-order kitchen with this versatile and easy-to-use Lodge carbon steel griddle.

Zadora Premium 14" Carbon Steel Griddle


I’ve been using the Zadora 14" Carbon Steel Comal for a while now and I’ve come to appreciate both its positive and negative aspects. When I first received it, I was pleasantly surprised by its sturdy structure and how evenly it heated food. It’s perfect for cooking tortillas, roasting veggies, and searing meat, and the non-stick interior makes cleaning up a breeze.

However, I’ve noticed that food tends to stick to it more than other pans I’ve used, especially during the first few uses. It’s a bit of a hassle to scrub off any leftover stuck bits. Another issue is its relatively low durability; the surface does wear down over time, which is disappointing given its price.

On the bright side, I love its visual appeal and craftsmanship. It looks and feels high-quality, which adds to my overall satisfaction. Despite the small hiccups, I’ve grown to appreciate the Zadora Comal and find it to be a useful addition to my kitchen collection.

Overall, it’s a bit hit and miss, but if you’re looking for a sturdy, attractive kitchen essential that heats evenly, you may want to give this Comal a try.

Buyer’s Guide

Welcome to the buyer’s guide for Carbon Steel Griddles! This comprehensive guide will provide you with essential information about essential features, considerations, and general advice to assist you in purchasing the perfect Carbon Steel Griddle for your needs. Here, we’ll explore some factors to bear in mind as you navigate the market to ensure you acquire a quality product that can last for years.

Important Features to Consider

As you begin your search for the perfect Carbon Steel Griddle, there are several vital features to take into account. These include the heating and cooling mechanisms, the size and shape of the griddle, the construction material’s quality, and the presence of specific safety features. Let’s delve deeper into understanding these aspects.

Size and Shape of the Griddle

One of the primary considerations is the size and shape of the Carbon Steel Griddle. The size you choose will depend on the amount and type of food you’ll be cooking and the space available on your stovetop or counter. It is essential to determine the optimal size based on your cooking requirements, ensuring you don’t purchase a griddle that’s either too small or too large for your needs.

Heating and Cooling Mechanisms

The heating and cooling mechanism is another crucial factor to consider when shopping for a Carbon Steel Griddle. The ideal model will provide even heating across the entire cooking surface and quick, efficient cooling for optimal temperature control. Look for models with adjustable thermostats to manage the temperature as needed, ensuring your food is cooked to perfection.

Construction Material’s Quality

Carbon Steel Griddles are known for their durability and long-lasting performance, but it’s essential to choose a model built with high-quality materials. The steel should be smooth, even, and non-stick, with no rough edges. Opt for models with thicker steel construction for better heat distribution and a more uniform cooking surface.


What is a carbon steel griddle?

A carbon steel griddle is a type of cooking surface made from carbon steel, which is a strong, durable, and lightweight material. It is designed to evenly distribute heat across its surface for cooking various dishes, from pancakes and eggs to burgers and steaks. Carbon steel griddles are known for their versatility, ease of use, and longevity.

Carbon steel griddles are ideal for both residential and commercial use, as they can handle high temperatures and are relatively easy to clean. However, they require proper seasoning and maintenance to ensure optimal performance and longevity. These griddles are available in various sizes, shapes, and designs, catering to different cooking needs and preferences.

What are the advantages of using a carbon steel griddle over other cooking surfaces?

There are several advantages of using a carbon steel griddle over other cooking surfaces. Firstly, carbon steel is an excellent heat conductor, ensuring even heating and cooking of the food. This ensures that the dishes turned out do not have any cold spots or burnt areas. Secondly, carbon steel griddles are lightweight and portable, making them easy to move and store. Thirdly, they are easy to clean and maintain, as they do not absorb food particles or odors easily.

Additionally, carbon steel griddles can be seasoned and polished to achieve a non-stick surface, eliminating the need for additional cooking sprays or oils. This ensures that the food does not stick to the surface, making cleanup and maintenance even more comfortable. They are also resistant to corrosion and rust, which ensures their longevity and consistent performance over an extended period.

What is the best way to care for a carbon steel griddle?

Proper care and maintenance of a carbon steel griddle are essential to ensure its longevity and optimal performance. The following are some key tips for caring for your carbon steel griddle: Firstly, always preheat your griddle to the desired temperature before adding any food. This helps to ensure even heating and cooking of the dishes. Secondly, never immerse your griddle in water or use abrasive cleaners to wash it, as this can damage the seasoning and surface.

Instead, use a soft, non-abrasive sponge or cloth and a small amount of warm, soapy water to clean the griddle. Make sure to rinse it thoroughly and dry it immediately to prevent any rusting. It is also recommended to re-season your griddle periodically, usually once every few months, to maintain its non-stick surface and longevity.

What are some common cooking tips for using a carbon steel griddle?

To get the most out of your carbon steel griddle, follow these tips when cooking: Firstly, always preheat the griddle to the desired temperature before adding any food. This helps to ensure that the griddle is evenly heated and that your dishes cook evenly. Secondly, add a small amount of oil or cooking spray to the griddle surface before cooking to prevent the food from sticking.

Once your food is cooking, avoid turning it too early or too often, as this can affect the cooking time and consistency of the dish. Instead, wait until the food has developed a golden-brown crust before flipping or turning it. Finally, remember to let your griddle cool down before cleaning it, as this will prevent any damage to the surface. Proper care and use of your carbon steel griddle will ensure that it performs optimally for years to come.

What are some popular carbon steel griddle models on the market?

There are several popular carbon steel griddle models on the market, catering to different cooking needs and preferences. Some of the most well-known brands include Lodge, GreenLife, and T-Fal. Each brand offers various sizes, shapes, and styles of carbon steel griddles, including flat griddles, raised griddles, and combination griddles. It is recommended to research and compare the features and specifications of each model before making a purchase to ensure that you find the best option for your cooking requirements.

Some popular models include the Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Square Griddle (12-Inch), GreenLife Soft Grip Ceramic Griddle, and T-Fal SW610S Professional Nonstick Griddle (16-Inch). These griddles are known for their durability, ease of use, and versatility, making them ideal for a variety of culinary applications.

Can I use a carbon steel griddle for cooking outdoors?

Yes, carbon steel griddles are an excellent choice for outdoor cooking, due to their lightweight, portable, and durable nature. They are suitable for use on gas, charcoal, and even open fire, making them versatile and convenient for outdoor gatherings and events. When cooking outdoors, make sure to follow the same tips for care and maintenance as you would when using your griddle indoors, to ensure optimal performance and longevity.

Additionally, it is essential to consider the size and weight of the griddle when choosing an outdoor cooking surface, as well as the type of fuel used. Carbon steel griddles are available in various sizes and designs to suit different cooking needs, so it is recommended to research and compare the features of each model before making a purchase.

As an Amazon Associate, we receive compensation from qualifying purchases!